Mainnavigation

      • DE
      • EN
    • Watchlist
    • Menu Menu

    Can excellence be taught?

    From the university magazine Zett

    How do collective and personal excellence differ? Illustration from the series โ€œTracksโ€ by Brigitte von Arx.

    Published on 30.07.2023

    Author Florian Pezzatti

    • Campus

    Studying arts subjects is meant to develop an individualโ€™s abilities, to foster new skills, and to unlock potential. Can excellence also be taught, and if so, how? A comment by Florian Pezzatti, member of the student organisation Verso.

    The term โ€œexcellenceโ€ first appeared in 1982 in a management book by Tom Peters and Robert Waterman. Titled In Search of Excellence, their study describes a company that can adapt, act with foresight and anticipate future demand. In 1999, โ€œexcellenceโ€ slipped into the education sector following the Bologna reforms and subsequently became used increasingly in political debate. Its precise meaning, however, has yet to be debated, and many interpretations exist as a result. 

    The root word ex cella means โ€œbeyond the storeroomโ€ or, figuratively speaking, โ€œbeyond the accustomed habitatโ€. Excellence thus demands expanding boundaries, breaking out of the cell(ar) as a familiar habitat, growing beyond customary confines and standing out from the familiar. Contrary to the honorary address โ€œYour Excellenceโ€, the term now denotes the temporary outcome of productive endeavour. We cannot possess excellence, since it is a perishable commodity, and instead must keep expanding our boundaries.

    I distinguish four perspectives on excellence:

    โ€ข Excellence can be a possible goal of personality development โ€” especially venturing โ€œbeyond the accustomed habitatโ€;

    โ€ข Excellence is a popular way for institutions to present themselves to the outside world;

    โ€ข Guaranteeing excellence enables political accountability;

    โ€ข To make themselves visible in todayโ€™s performance-driven society, individuals often need to present themselves as outstanding.

    Visibility (or demanding) serves as both justification and critique.

    Florian Pezzatti

    Institutions must regularly use excellence to promote and justify themselves; after all, who would cut their funding if they produce nothing less than excellence? Traditionally, certain forms of excellence have attracted special attention. Technical virtuosity has, for instance, due to its relative measurability.

    Yet what about those forms of excellence that are neither measurable nor always presentable, and thus less visible? I propose distinguishing between collective and personal excellence. Collective excellence is a very rare โ€œawardโ€ for achievements extending beyond the standards of a particular discipline. Personal excellence, on the other hand, is excellence on a small scale. Personal excellence is highly individual and can be achieved by all. We cannot, however, possess it and can attain it only by surpassing ourselves. Thereafter, we are โ€” and are also allowed to be โ€” average again.

    No one constantly excels: we do so only in certain situations and at particular activities.

    Florian Pezzatti

    My wish for higher education is that it serves as both guide and companion, shows students possibilities and supports them on their chosen path. If achieving excellence requires me to reach beyond or break out of my own domain, that is a personal matter. For me, standing out means performing exceptionally well in relation to myself or others within a limited amount of time. By transgressing our confines, we expand our limits.

    It is about realizing our potential through constant striving. Educators and facilitators can help students learn about their own spheres, limits and resonances and find ways of rediscovering, differentiating and further developing these assets. However, knowing and expanding our potentials and limits to fully utilize our resources is instrinsic: it must happen within us as learning individuals. What can be taught is merely what already exists. Excellence is what rises above what is given.


    FLORIAN PEZZATTI

    Florian Pezzatti (mail) is doing a Master of Arts in School Music II.


    Verso

    The student organisation Verso represents the rights and interests of students at ZHdK. Verso representatives sit on various committees and exchange ideas on student affairs with the University Board and various committees.
     

    • Twitter
    • Facebook
    • LinkedIn

    Discover more

    • Campus
      • Digitalization Initiative of the Zurich Higher Education Institutions (DIZH)

        Bridge professor Roland Meyer at the re:publica 25

      • From the university magazine Zett

        Springboard into studying music

      • From the university magazine Zett

        โ€œThe Red Herringโ€

      • Bewerbung bis 16. Juni 2025

        Call for Projects: Innovatives Publizieren in Open Science